Aston Villa’s fortunes have drastically changed in a year, from Champions League quarter-finalists to Carabao Cup disappointment. Unai Emery faces mounting pressure as the team struggles to replicate last season’s success, with a penalty shootout defeat to Brentford highlighting their current woes. Can they turn it around?
A year ago, Aston Villa was riding high, embarking on a Champions League journey that would see them reach the quarter-finals, facing off against Paris Saint-Germain (PSG) in a memorable encounter. Their campaign began with a resounding 3-0 victory over Young Boys, showcasing a level of fluidity and dynamism that had fans dreaming of European glory. It was Aston Villa's return to Europe's elite competition after a 41-year absence, and the team, led by Unai Emery, seemed unstoppable.
The momentum continued as they dispatched Bayern Munich with a similarly impressive performance, further solidifying their status as a force to be reckoned with. Unai Emery's tactical masterclass and the exceptional performances of players like Jhon Durán and John McGinn contributed to the team's early-season success, with their play as smooth as Ozzy Osbourne's hair in the Birmingham breeze.
However, fast forward to September 2025, and the situation couldn't be more different. While the Champions League spotlight shone elsewhere, Aston Villa found themselves in a Carabao Cup match against Brentford, a stark contrast to their European exploits of the previous year. The match ended in a penalty shootout defeat, marking an early exit from the competition and highlighting the team's struggles this season.
Despite the loss, there was a glimmer of hope as Aston Villa managed to score a goal, a feat they hadn't achieved in their previous four games. Harvey Elliott's goal, though somewhat fortuitous due to a Brentford backpass error and a goalkeeping blunder, provided a brief moment of celebration. However, Brentford quickly responded, capitalizing on a long throw to level the score and ultimately defeat Villa in the shootout.
Unai Emery acknowledged the team's need for improvement, stating, "I think we're getting better – there’s still work to do and we’re going to practice." He also highlighted the integration of new players into the squad, emphasizing their need for playing time to gain confidence and adapt to the team's structure. Emery praised John McGinn's pressing and the team's creation of three or four clear chances, including a shot that hit the post by Jadon Sancho.
While Emery attempted to maintain a positive outlook, the reality is that Aston Villa's performance against Brentford was far from convincing. Jadon Sancho's missed opportunity, a simple tap-in that he directed onto the post instead of into the net, epitomized the team's struggles in front of goal. The defeat in the Carabao Cup has added to the pressure on Emery, and the upcoming match against Sunderland will be crucial in determining the team's direction.
The fans, known for their passionate support, are growing increasingly frustrated with the team's recent performances. The optimism that surrounded Aston Villa a year ago has dissipated, replaced by uncertainty and concern. Unless Emery can quickly turn things around, the pressure will continue to mount, and the dream of European success will fade further into the distance. What a difference a year makes.
Meanwhile, in other news, Simon Burnton provided live updates on Liverpool's 3-1 victory over Atlético Madrid in the Champions League, while Luke McLaughlin covered Bayern Munich's 1-1 draw with Chelsea.
Oliver Glasner, when discussing Romain Esse's performance in Crystal Palace's Milk Cup win over Millwall, stated, "I don’t want to talk about a single player but of course if you sub somebody at half-time you are not pleased with his performance. I will talk to him in person and then it’s up to him to show improvement. That’s it."
Richie Philpott responded to yesterday’s Football Daily, saying, "Qarabag ‘whipping-boy chaff’ (yesterday’s Football Daily). Funny, Bruno Lage thought so too."
John Waugh writes, "Has it ever occurred to my learned friends at Football Daily (OK, our sarcasm antennae is really starting to twitch now – Football Daily Ed) that perhaps one of the reasons three dozen teams are playing a dozen-dozen games in Bigger Cup’s first stage and some people still turn up to watch, is because they actually like football. Whether a particular fixture confirms their own team as crowned champions of Europe is maybe for most fans not of great import. I presume most followers of the ‘whipping-boy chaff’ go for the love of their team and some maybe even for the love of the game. Whilst no doubt generating a fat load of dosh, Uefa’s ‘Swiss Model’ also allows fans to watch more football and see their team play more other teams. Is this such a bad thing? Even if this means enduring ‘meaningless’ fixtures such as last night’s mind-numbing dead-rubber between Juventus and Borussia Dortmund. I also presume that the legendary Algerian goalkeeper Albert Camus enjoyed playing in goal for Racing Universitaire d’Alger, even though he was convinced that life was entirely devoid of meaning."
Noble Francis writes, "Kevin Mac Allister (aka Alexis Mac Allister’s brother) scoring the winner for Union Saint-Gilloise away at PSV gives me the excuse to bring out one of my favourite, pointless pieces of trivia. He is named after the Kevin McCallister character in Home Alone played by Macaulay Culkin but he wasn’t aware of it and used to joke about the coincidence whenever it was mentioned, until he found out from his parents when he was 18 that he actually was named after him. To quote the great Philip Larkin, ‘They mess* you up, your mum and dad.’ The language has been changed as the original is far too rude, but Larkin was bang on …"
Mike Slattery writes, "Re: ‘There’s a tradition in the Mediterranean, especially in Greece and Cyprus, of doing some olive oil really early in the season. It’s not new. It’s thousands of years old’ (Tuesday’s breakout section – full email edition). That endless Peloponnesian war between Athens and Sparta was sparked by a disputed offside call, it turns out"
If you have any, please send letters to the.boss@theguardian.com. Today’s winner of our letter o’ the day is … Richie Philpott, who wins some Football Weekly merch.
The latest Football Weekly podcast is ready for your ears, right here.
This is an extract from our daily football email … Football Daily. To get the full version, just visit this page and follow the instructions.