Celtic’s Transfer Strategy Under Fire: Pundits and Fans Slam ‘PR Disaster’
September 7, 2025
Celtic’s attempt to defend their transfer window strategy has been met with widespread criticism, labeled a ‘PR disaster’ by pundits and fans alike. The club’s statement, intended to quell supporter unrest, has instead amplified discontent, with many questioning the lack of ambition and transparency. Former players and fans have voiced their concerns over the timing of transfers, the failure to adequately replace key players, and the apparent prioritization of financial reserves over squad strengthening. The backlash underscores a growing disconnect between the board and the fanbase, placing immense pressure on Celtic’s leadership to address the concerns and restore faith in the club’s direction.
Celtic's recent attempts to justify their transfer window activity have backfired spectacularly, drawing harsh criticism from both pundits and fans. The club's statement, released late Saturday, asserting that "throwing money" around is "not a sustainable route to success," has been widely interpreted as tone-deaf and out of touch with supporter expectations. This communication, the first of its kind since the transfer window closed, aimed to quell growing unrest among the Celtic faithful, but instead, it has seemingly amplified their discontent.
The statement, in which Celtic claimed to take fan opinions "extremely seriously," understand "the concerns and frustrations," and remain "always willing to learn lessons," has been perceived as patronizing and deflective. Rather than calming the waters, it has ignited a storm of criticism, with many questioning the club's ambition and direction.
Image source, SNS
Image caption,
Celtic fans displayed banners at a recent game against Livingston
Michael Stewart, a former Scotland midfielder, didn't hold back, labeling the statement an "absolute PR disaster." He criticized the club's inability to "read the room" and suggested that silence would have been a more prudent course of action. Stewart emphasized the statement's failure to acknowledge any shortcomings in the club's transfer dealings, arguing that a simple "sorry" would have been more effective.
James McFadden, another former Scotland international, echoed these sentiments, focusing on the timing of Celtic's transfer activity. He stressed the importance of securing players before key Champions League qualifiers, a deadline the club failed to meet. McFadden acknowledged the success of Celtic's model over the years but deemed the recent transfer window, and the one preceding it, as "not been good enough."
The backlash from Celtic fans has been equally fierce. Online forums and social media platforms are flooded with expressions of anger and disappointment. One fan, identified as Arthur, described the statement as "condescending drivel," while another, David, lamented the club's apparent prioritization of financial reserves over squad strengthening. Colin vowed to withhold spending until changes occur within the board, reflecting a growing sense of disillusionment among the Celtic support.
Ruairidh accused the club of lacking accountability and treating concerned fans with contempt, while Futileventure pointed to Celtic's alleged practice of "low-balling" potential transfer targets as a hindrance to recruitment. JC expressed bewilderment at how the board could expect progress without providing the manager with adequate resources, arguing that the board is failing the club.
Another David highlighted the failure to replace key players, questioning the amateurish nature of the club's recruitment process and demanding greater transparency. Brian dismissed the statement as a "smoke-screen," accusing the club of taking loyal supporters and their cash for granted. Andrew sarcastically thanked Celtic for clarifying their efforts, while questioning the unique challenges they face compared to other clubs.
Celtic have signed 12 players since the end of last season, but Sebastian Tounekti, Michel-Ange Balikwisha and Kelechi Iheanacho only arrived after the club's Champions League hopes were ended by Kazakhstan's Kairat Almaty. Many fans feel players such as Kyogo Furuhashi, Adam Idah, Nicolas Kuhn have not been adequately replaced despite the significant profit generated by their sales.
The club's explanation that healthy cash reserves are "not relevant" to Uefa's financial regulations, a factor cited as hindering player signings, has also been met with skepticism. The claim that "inaccurate or misleading information" prompted the demand for clarity has further fueled the perception of a disconnect between the board and the fanbase.
As Celtic navigate this turbulent period, the pressure is mounting on the club's leadership to address the concerns of supporters and demonstrate a renewed commitment to on-field success. The coming weeks and months will be crucial in determining whether Celtic can bridge the divide with their fanbase and restore faith in the club's direction.
