Chelsea and Liverpool dominated headlines this summer, but not for the reasons you might think. While other clubs splashed the cash, these two Premier League giants seemingly secured some of the biggest bargains of the 2025 transfer window. Let’s delve into the deals that have pundits debating whether these signings represent shrewd acquisitions or calculated gambles.
Estevao Willian (Palmeiras to Chelsea): Chelsea secured Willian for a fee of £29m, potentially rising to £52m – matching his Transfermarkt valuation. While this seemingly avoids overpaying, the success hinges on triggering those significant add-ons, which are likely performance-based. His arrival, orchestrated by then-manager Mauricio Pochettino, adds another layer of intrigue to this transfer.
Florian Wirtz (Bayer Leverkusen to Liverpool): Liverpool’s British record-breaking £100m (potentially £116m) signing of Wirtz from Bayer Leverkusen also raises eyebrows. While slightly below his Transfermarkt valuation of £121.3m, the add-ons suggest Liverpool’s success with Wirtz will determine the true value of this deal. The speed of the transfer, and Liverpool’s subsequent spending, somewhat masks the audacity of securing a player coveted by European giants.
Jeremie Frimpong (Bayer Leverkusen to Liverpool): Liverpool’s acquisition of Frimpong for £29.5m (below his £43.3m valuation) has generated some debate. The signing of another attacking right-back, despite defensive concerns, highlights Liverpool’s willingness to exploit a favorable release clause.
Rayan Cherki (Lyon to Manchester City): Manchester City’s pursuit of narrative-driven signings continues with Cherki. His £30.45m (potentially £34m) arrival, below his £39m valuation, adds intrigue. The move signals a change in direction for City, seeking creative flair as key players approach the end of their careers. Cherki’s bold Ballon d’Or aspirations further underscore the potential of this signing.
Liam Delap (Ipswich to Chelsea): Chelsea’s £30m capture of Delap from Ipswich showcases the influence of release clauses. Ipswich’s initial investment and Delap’s prolific first Premier League season made him a hot commodity. This signing, while slightly below his £34.7m valuation, demonstrates Chelsea’s willingness to act decisively in the market.
These under-the-radar deals highlight the complexities of the modern transfer market. While some may seem like bargains, the success of these signings will depend on performance, add-ons, and the overall impact on their respective teams. The coming season will be crucial in determining whether these clubs truly secured value or took considerable risks.