Player Ratings: 3/10 Martinez let’s Reds down as Leeds grabs first Old Trafford win in 44 years

Player Ratings: 3/10 Martinez let’s Reds down as Leeds grabs first Old Trafford win in 44 years

Manchester United missed a vital opportunity to cement third place in the Premier League after a disastrous 2-1 home defeat to Leeds United, marred by a bizarre red card for Lisandro Martinez.

​Manchester United endured a night to forget at Old Trafford, suffering a 2-1 loss to rivals Leeds United. The hosts were booed off at the interval following a brace from Noah Okafor, as Michael Carrick’s side struggled to find any rhythm.

While Casemiro’s second-half header sparked hopes of a comeback, the dismissal of Lisandro Martinez for pulling Dominic Calvert-Lewin’s hair left the Red Devils with too much to do.

Leeds held firm to secure a historic victory, boosting their survival hopes while halting United’s momentum.

​Senne Lammens: 6/10

The goalkeeper kept United in the game early with a sharp stop against Calvert-Lewin. While he was largely blameless for Okafor’s double, a lapse in concentration saw him play a dangerous ball that nearly gifted Leeds a third. He redeemed himself later with a crucial save from Pascal Struijk to prevent a complete first-half collapse.

​Noussair Mazraoui: 3/10

It was a night to forget for the full-back, who struggled to impact the game on either end. His lack of composure was highlighted by a wild long-range effort that sailed harmlessly away from goal. After a peripheral 69 minutes where he failed to contain the opposition, he was eventually withdrawn for Diogo Dalot.

​Leny Yoro: 4/10

The young defender found life difficult against the physical presence of Calvert-Lewin, losing out in the air for Leeds’ opening goal. Luck was also against him as Okafor’s second effort deflected off his frame and into the net. Throughout the match, he appeared rattled by the intensity of the Leeds front line.

​Lisandro Martinez: 3/10

Returning from a calf injury, the Argentine looked sluggish and off the pace. While he produced one sensational goal-line intervention to keep the score at 2-0, his performance was overshadowed by an act of “brainless” indiscipline. A VAR review confirmed he pulled an opponent’s hair, leading to a straight red card that killed United’s momentum.

​Luke Shaw: 4/10

The veteran defender struggled with his positioning, often leaving massive gaps behind him that Jayden Bogle exploited. While he showed flashes of quality with his tackling and one searching long ball, he was booked for a tactical foul and frustrated the fans by failing to deliver crosses quickly during the closing stages.

​Casemiro: 7/10

Despite an early error that led to the second Leeds goal, the Brazilian was United’s most influential player. He balanced ambitious passing with defensive grit and gave the fans hope with a powerful headed goal. He was inches away from securing a dramatic equalizer, only for his late header to be cleared off the line.

​Manuel Ugarte: 3/10

Ugarte struggled significantly with the pace of the game, failing to track the run that led to the opening cross. His distribution remained limited, and his defensive contributions were insufficient to shield the back four. He moved to center-back late in the game, where he looked slightly more settled, but his starting stint was poor.

​Matheus Cunha: 5/10

Cunha’s evening was a mix of frustration and wasted potential. He was cautioned for simulation and struggled to connect with his teammates in the final third. While he improved in the second half and tested Karl Darlow with a few stinging efforts, his final ball often lacked the necessary precision to break the deadlock.

​Bruno Fernandes: 7/10

The captain remains the heartbeat of the side, registering his 17th assist of the campaign with a pinpoint cross for Casemiro. Despite his constant complaints to the officials and a yellow card for dissent, he was the primary source of creativity and the only player consistently capable of threatening the Leeds defense.

​Amad Diallo: 6/10

Amad was the brightest spark in a dull first-half performance, using his flair to bypass defenders and force a save from the keeper. He created a golden opportunity for Sesko early on, but his influence waned as the match progressed, leading to his substitution as United searched for a different approach.

​Benjamin Sesko: 5/10

The striker had a frustrating evening, highlighted by a tame effort when played through on goal at 0-0. He was physically competitive and nearly scored after the break, but he missed a late, high-quality chance to level the scoring from a cross, summing up a night of missed opportunities for the forward.

​Bryan Mbeumo: 7/10

Coming on as a second-half substitute, Mbeumo provided an immediate spark and much-needed directness. He was denied a goal by a sensational defensive block and provided a perfect delivery that should have resulted in an equalizer. His energy gave the ten men of United a genuine late fighting chance.

​Diogo Dalot: 6/10

Replacing Mazraoui for the final twenty minutes, Dalot offered more stability and intent down the flank. While he didn’t have enough time to completely change the complexion of the game, he looked far more comfortable than the man he replaced and helped sustain the pressure during the final onslaught.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top